Questions for the Gore
Former Vice President Al Gore was in Madison yesterday speaking to the “Society of Environmental Journalists” conference, not exactly an objective bunch. (I wrote about the appearance last week for the Waukesha Freeman.)
The MacIver Institute was there when one film-maker, Phelim McAleer, decided to ask a serious question.
The Wisconsin State Journal reported on the mood of at least one “journalist” and on the protest outside:
Some who attended the speech tempered Gore’s hopefulness, characteristic of his lauded yet controversial effort to educate the public about carbon dioxide emissions and their link to rising temperatures.
“His optimism isn’t shared by a lot of other folks,” said Tim Wheeler, an environmental reporter for the Baltimore Sun. Gore may have been trying to push politicians to action, Wheeler added.
Conservative groups led by Collegians for a Constructive Tomorrow and Americans for Prosperity held a demonstration Downtown that drew about 200 people, including U.S. Rep. James Sensenbrenner, R-Menomonee Falls, who also participated in the conference’s panel discussion following Gore’s speech. The demonstrators worried Gore’s policies would push American jobs overseas.
Gore has been criticized for not publicly debating his position since the release of his 2006 Oscar-winning documentary, “An Inconvenient Truth.”
In what organizers said was a rarity, Gore took half a dozen questions from journalists, including one from Phelim McAleer, an Irish filmmaker who asked Gore to address nine errors in his film identified by a British court in 2007.
Gore responded that the court ruling supported the showing of his film in British schools. When McAleer tried to debate further, his microphone was cut off by the moderators.


McAleer seems to like to claim he’s a journalist rather than one of those Michael Moore-esque documentary filmmakers, right down to wearing the just-a-regular-guy untucked t-shirt when asking the tough questions on the red carpet. It’s much harder for him to get an actual sit-down interview, hmm?
I think you’re no longer a “journalist” and more like an editorialist when the proclamation of your personal value judgements become the story. Anti-American, said the Irishman? They want us to change the way we live! They want to raise our taxes! The most controversial film of the year! Back to the Dark Ages and the Black Plague!
Does the Heartland Institute pay their experts? I wonder who paid him to research the Romanian sex workers and say that sex slaves don’t exist.
[Reply]